Published on and written by Cyril Jarnias
Choosing the appropriate legal structure for establishing a business in Bulgaria is a crucial step to maximize success opportunities in this country with multiple economic prospects. The two most common legal forms, LLC (limited liability company) and JSC (joint stock company), each offer specific advantages that can influence your business’s development and management. While LLCs are often favored for their flexibility and minimal share capital requirements, JSCs stand out through their ability to raise funds more easily through stock issuance. This article explores in detail the key differences between these two company types, helping you make an informed choice based on your entrepreneurial project’s unique goals and needs in Bulgaria.
Understanding the Differences Between LLC and JSC
Limited Liability Company (LLC) vs Joint Stock Company (JSC) in Bulgaria
Bulgaria offers two main legal forms for entrepreneurs looking to establish a business: the limited liability company (LLC) and the joint stock company (JSC). While these two structures share some similarities, they present significant differences in terms of structure, liability, and legal requirements.
Legal Structure and Liability
The LLC is a more flexible structure, suitable for small and medium-sized businesses. It can be established by a single member (Sole Member LLC) or multiple members (up to 50). Member liability is limited to their contributions, thus protecting their personal assets.
The JSC, on the other hand, is designed for large companies and those considering going public. It requires at least two shareholders (or seven for listed companies). As with LLCs, shareholder liability is limited to their contributions.
The most striking difference between these two legal forms lies in share capital requirements:
For LLCs, the minimum share capital is only 2 BGN (approximately 1 EUR), making it very accessible to beginning entrepreneurs.
For JSCs, the minimum share capital is set at 50,000 BGN (approximately 25,000 EUR), reflecting its purpose to accommodate larger-scale projects.
The establishment process is generally simpler and faster for an LLC. Required documents include the articles of association, minutes of the constituent assembly, and signature specimens of managers. For a JSC, additional formalities are required, including the appointment of a board of directors or management board and a supervisory board.
Governance and Decision-Making
In an LLC, the governance structure is simpler. Important decisions are made during the general meeting of members. Daily management is handled by one or more managers, who can be members or third parties.
For a JSC, the structure is more complex. It must include a general meeting of shareholders and a board of directors (single-tier system) or a management board and supervisory board (dual-tier system). This structure allows for a clearer separation between company ownership and management.
Tax and Accounting Obligations
Both company types are subject to the same corporate tax rate, currently 10% in Bulgaria. However, accounting and audit requirements may vary:
Small LLCs can benefit from simplified accounting procedures and are generally not required to have their annual accounts audited.
JSCs, on the other hand, are subject to stricter accounting obligations and must generally have their annual accounts audited by an independent accountant.
Advantages and Disadvantages: Concrete Examples
For a tech startup with limited resources but strong growth potential, an LLC could be the ideal choice. It allows quick setup with low initial capital while offering the necessary flexibility to adapt to rapid market changes.
For a manufacturing company seeking to attract institutional investors and considering international expansion, a JSC would be more appropriate. Its more formal structure and ability to issue listed stock facilitate raising significant capital.
In an LLC, the transfer of membership interests is generally subject to approval by other members and must be registered with the commercial register. This restriction may limit investment liquidity but offers better control over shareholder composition.
For a JSC, shares are freely transferable unless otherwise provided in the articles of association. This increased liquidity can be an advantage for attracting investors but may also make the company more vulnerable to hostile takeovers.
Flexibility and Evolution
The LLC offers greater flexibility in daily management and adaptation to market changes. For example, an LLC can easily modify its business purpose or internal structure through a simple decision by the general meeting of members.
The JSC, although more rigid in structure, offers unique possibilities for growth and expansion. It can, for example, raise funds more easily by issuing new shares or convertible bonds.
When choosing between an LLC and a JSC, entrepreneurs must consider not only their current needs but also their future aspirations. An LLC may be ideal for starting up, but conversion to a JSC could become necessary if the company experiences rapid growth and requires significant capital.
Good to know:
In Bulgaria, a limited liability company (LLC) requires a minimum share capital of 2 BGN and is ideal for small and medium-sized businesses, as it allows liability limited to member contributions without obligation to publish accounts. Conversely, the joint stock company (JSC) requires a minimum capital of 50,000 BGN, making its establishment more formal with boards of directors and increased transparency obligations, making it more suitable for large companies considering public fundraising. For example, a tech startup might prefer an LLC for its simplicity and reduced cost, while a company looking to go public would opt for a JSC to meet investor expectations. Tax-wise, both types are subject to corporate tax, but a JSC faces mandatory audits and stricter reporting requirements.
Advantages of Establishing an LLC in Bulgaria
Tax Benefits of an LLC
Establishing an LLC in Bulgaria offers significant tax benefits compared to other legal forms like JSCs. The corporate tax rate in Bulgaria is one of the lowest in the European Union, set at only 10%. This rate applies uniformly to LLCs and JSCs, but LLCs benefit from a simpler structure that can facilitate tax optimization. Additionally, the dividend tax rate is particularly advantageous for LLCs, amounting to only 5%, one of the lowest in the EU.
One of the most attractive features of the LLC is its minimal share capital requirement. Unlike JSCs which require minimum capital of 50,000 BGN (approximately 25,000 EUR), an LLC can be established with share capital of only 2 BGN (approximately 1 EUR). This extremely low entry barrier makes LLCs particularly attractive for entrepreneurs and small businesses starting with limited resources.
Simplified Administrative Procedures
Establishing an LLC in Bulgaria is characterized by its simplicity and speed. The registration process can be completed in a few days, typically between 3 and 5 business days if all documents are in order. This administrative efficiency contrasts with the more complex and time-consuming procedures associated with establishing a JSC.
Limited Liability and Personal Asset Protection
The LLC offers crucial legal protection to entrepreneurs in the form of limited liability. Shareholders are only responsible for company debts up to their investment in the company. This characteristic effectively protects owners’ personal assets, offering significant financial security, particularly for small and medium-sized businesses.
Operational and Management Flexibility
The LLC structure allows great flexibility in management and decision-making. Unlike JSCs which require a board of directors, an LLC can be managed by a single director, who can also be the sole shareholder. This simplified structure facilitates quick decision-making and adaptation to market changes. Additionally, LLCs enjoy greater freedom in defining their internal structure and management processes, allowing customization tailored to the company’s specific needs.
Good to know:
Establishing an LLC in Bulgaria presents numerous advantages, particularly tax-wise, with a corporate tax rate set at 10%, significantly lower than some other forms like JSCs. Additionally, the initial required share capital is minimal, often set at 2 leva, making it attractive for small entrepreneurs. The administrative procedure for establishing an LLC is simplified, typically requiring only a few days for registration, allowing quick business setup. Legally, entrepreneurs benefit from liability limited to their contribution amount, providing significant protection. Finally, the LLC offers management flexibility with the possibility to choose between several management configurations and simplifies decision-making for owners.
Benefits of Opting for a JSC
Tax Benefits of JSCs in Bulgaria
Adopting JSC (Joint Stock Company) status in Bulgaria offers significant tax benefits for entrepreneurs. With a corporate tax rate of only 10%, one of the lowest in the European Union, JSCs benefit from a particularly attractive tax environment. Additionally, dividends paid to resident shareholders in Bulgaria are tax-exempt, allowing interesting tax optimization for investors.
Administrative Simplicity Compared to LLCs
Although JSCs require higher minimum share capital than LLCs, their administrative structure is often simpler and more flexible. JSCs allow clear separation between company ownership and management, with the possibility to opt for a single or two-tier management system. This flexibility allows entrepreneurs to choose the structure best suited to their needs, thus facilitating decision-making and daily business management.
JSCs offer great flexibility in share capital management. Entrepreneurs can easily increase or reduce company capital by issuing new shares or repurchasing existing shares. This flexibility is particularly advantageous for rapidly growing companies or those seeking to attract new investors.
Personal Asset Protection
One of the main advantages of JSCs is the limited liability they offer shareholders. In case of commercial disputes or company bankruptcy, shareholders are only liable up to their investment in the company. This personal asset protection is a major asset for entrepreneurs wishing to limit their exposure to financial risks.
Success Examples
Several Bulgarian companies have achieved remarkable success by adopting the JSC structure. For example, Fibank, one of Bulgaria’s largest banks, chose this legal form to facilitate its expansion and attract international investors. Similarly, Sopharma, a leader in the Bulgarian pharmaceutical industry, used the JSC structure to finance its growth and internationalization.
Regulatory Advantages
Bulgaria has implemented simplified procedures for establishing and managing JSCs, particularly in terms of financial reporting and corporate governance. These favorable regulations, combined with the possibility to quickly obtain an intra-community VAT number, make JSCs an attractive option for entrepreneurs wishing to operate in the European market.
Good to know:
Opting for a JSC in Bulgaria presents several advantages, including tax benefits such as a reduced tax rate compared to other structures. The administrative structure of a JSC is simpler than that of an LLC, facilitating daily business management. Additionally, JSCs offer entrepreneurs great flexibility regarding share capital management, making it easier to attract investors. Shareholders also benefit from limited liability, protecting their personal assets in case of commercial disputes, as illustrated by the example of TechStartup JSC which prospered while protecting its founders from personal financial commitments. Finally, favorable regulations and simplified procedures for JSCs further encourage entrepreneurs to choose this structure, thus facilitating administrative procedures when establishing a business.
Criteria for Choosing the Right Legal Structure
Selection Criteria Between LLC and JSC in Bulgaria
When choosing between an LLC (Limited Liability Company) and a JSC (Joint Stock Company) in Bulgaria, several key criteria must be considered:
Financial Liability
Shareholder liability is a crucial factor. In an LLC, liability is limited to contribution amounts, offering personal asset protection. For a JSC, liability is also limited, but with a more formal structure that can reassure investors about the company’s financial solidity.
Administrative Flexibility
LLCs generally offer greater flexibility in daily management. Decisions can be made more quickly, which is ideal for small and medium-sized businesses. JSCs, on the other hand, have a more rigid structure with mandatory board of directors and shareholder meetings, which can slow certain decision-making processes but offers better governance for large companies.
The minimum required capital is a major differentiating element. For an LLC, the minimum share capital is only 2 BGN (approximately 1 EUR), making it very accessible to beginning entrepreneurs. Conversely, a JSC requires minimum capital of 50,000 BGN (approximately 25,000 EUR), which can constitute an entry barrier for some projects.
Management Structure
Management structure varies considerably between the two forms. An LLC can be managed by one or more managers, offering a simple and direct structure. A JSC must have a board of directors with at least three members, which may be more appropriate for larger-scale companies requiring increased supervision.
Tax Implications
The tax regime is similar for both structures, with a corporate tax rate of 10% in Bulgaria. However, JSCs may benefit from certain tax advantages related to stock issuance and stock market transactions if listed.
Establishment and Operating Costs
Initial and operational costs are generally higher for JSCs due to stricter legal requirements. LLCs have lower formation and maintenance fees, which can be a decisive factor for startups and small businesses.
Ease of Fundraising
The ability to attract investment is an important criterion. JSCs have the advantage of being able to issue shares and be listed on stock exchanges, facilitating raising significant capital. LLCs, although more limited in financing options, can still attract private investors and obtain bank loans.
Impact on Partner Relations
The choice of legal structure can influence business partners’ and clients’ perception. JSCs can project an image of stability and professionalism, particularly useful in certain sectors or for government contracts. LLCs may be perceived as more flexible and responsive, which can be an advantage in innovative or rapidly evolving industries.
Concrete Examples
To illustrate, consider the example of a tech startup in Bulgaria. If the goal is rapid growth and attracting significant investment, a JSC might be preferable despite higher initial costs. Conversely, for a family-owned local service business, an LLC would offer the necessary flexibility and simplicity while minimizing costs and administrative formalities.
Ultimately, the choice between an LLC and JSC in Bulgaria will depend on the company’s long-term goals, its intended size, financing needs, and growth strategy. Entrepreneurs must carefully evaluate these criteria based on their business vision and the Bulgarian commercial environment to make an informed decision.
Good to know:
When establishing a company in Bulgaria, choosing between an LLC and JSC depends on several key criteria. Financial liability is limited for both structures, but LLCs require minimum share capital of one lev versus 50,000 leva for JSCs, which can influence establishment costs. LLCs offer greater administrative flexibility with fewer formalities for annual meetings and daily management, while JSCs, although more complex to administer, can raise funds more easily through stock issuance, advantageous for attracting investors. Tax-wise, both entities are subject to similar rates, but structure choice can influence business partners’ perception and access to external financing. For an entrepreneur seeking to partner with other parties, a JSC might be better perceived for its more robust governance structure. For example, a startup might prefer an LLC to begin due to reduced costs and formalities, while a company aiming to go public might opt for a JSC to facilitate access to international financial markets.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or professional advice. We encourage you to consult qualified experts before making any investment, real estate, or expatriation decisions. Although we strive to maintain up-to-date and accurate information, we do not guarantee the completeness, accuracy, or timeliness of the proposed content. As investment and expatriation involve risks, we disclaim any liability for potential losses or damages arising from the use of this site. Your use of this site confirms your acceptance of these terms and your understanding of the associated risks.
Cyril Jarnias is an independent expert in international wealth management with over 20 years of experience. As an expatriate himself, he is dedicated to helping individuals and business leaders build, protect, and pass on their wealth with complete peace of mind.
On his website, cyriljarnias.com, he shares his expertise on international real estate, offshore company formation, and expatriation.
Thanks to his expertise, he offers sound advice to optimize his clients' wealth management. Cyril Jarnias is also recognized for his appearances in many prestigious media outlets such as BFM Business, les Français de l’étranger, Le Figaro, Les Echos, and Mieux vivre votre argent, where he shares his knowledge and know-how in wealth management.
