Corporate Governance in Japan: Best Practices

Published on and written by Cyril Jarnias

In a world where transparency and ethics have become essential pillars, corporate governance in Japan stands out through unique practices that deserve special attention. Blending tradition and modernity, Japanese companies have developed management systems that not only ensure economic stability but also strengthen stakeholder confidence.

This article explores how Japan, with its management principles centered on consensus and cooperation, manages to navigate a globalized environment while preserving its cultural identity. From establishing audit committees to risk management, and the importance given to social responsibility, every aspect of this integrated approach will be examined to draw lessons of universal relevance.

Understanding Management Standards in Japan

Japanese management standards have maintained unique characteristics for many years, deeply rooted in traditional cultural values. These characteristics have significantly influenced how Japanese companies are managed and their decision-making processes.

Respect for Hierarchy and Importance of Human Relationships

In Japanese management standards, respect for hierarchy is a very important element. This concept is closely tied to the seniority system that permeates Japanese society as a whole. In many Japanese companies, promotions and salaries are typically determined based on age or length of service.

Take Toyota Motor Corporation as an example. The company maintained a seniority-based system for many years. Under this system, employees are promoted and receive salary increases based on their tenure. This fosters loyalty to the company and enables human resource development with a long-term perspective.

On the other hand, the importance of human relationships is also a characteristic of Japanese management standards. In the decision-making process, harmony and cooperation within the team are valued, in addition to individual skills and performance.

Importance of Consensus and Decision-Making Process

In Japanese corporate decision-making processes, consensus-building is extremely important. This is clearly demonstrated in the practice called nemawashi. Nemawashi is a process of gathering opinions from all relevant parties before a formal meeting or decision and reaching an agreement.

Consider Hitachi as an example. Before making important decisions, managers from relevant departments meet individually to discuss and align their opinions. This facilitates decision-making during formal meetings and minimizes friction during implementation.

The ringi-sho system is also characteristic of Japanese corporate decision-making processes. Ringi-sho is a tool that documents proposals or plans to obtain approval from all relevant parties. This ensures transparency in decision-making and clarifies responsibility.

Concept of Continuous Improvement (Kaizen)

The concept of continuous improvement (kaizen) holds a very important position in Japanese management standards. It’s the idea of constantly improving through small enhancements to overall increase efficiency and quality.

Take Sony as an example. The company encourages all employees to propose daily improvements to operational processes. These proposals are carefully reviewed, and those deemed effective are quickly implemented. Through this initiative, Sony consistently maintains the development of innovative products and efficient production processes.

Comparison with Western Practices

Japanese management standards differ in many respects from Western ones. For example, in Western companies, evaluations and promotions are typically based on individual skills and performance, and decision-making is often relatively top-down.

Take GE (General Electric) as an example. Employee evaluation is based on a rigorous performance rating system, with the top 20% receiving high compensation and promotion opportunities, while the bottom 10% may be dismissed. This is a very different approach from the seniority system of Japanese companies.

Recent Reforms and Changes

Due to globalization and external influences, Japanese management standards are also showing signs of change. Many Japanese companies are trying to find a balance between traditional management methods and Western approaches.

Take Uniqlo as an example. The company maintains traditional Japanese management methods while adopting a global perspective. They abandoned the seniority system and introduced a merit-based system, while preserving teamwork and participatory decision-making processes. This enhances their competitiveness in the global market while leveraging Japanese strengths.

Thus, although Japanese management standards are based on traditional values, they are gradually evolving to respond to the wave of globalization. Japanese companies are expected to continue reforming to leverage their strengths and maintain international competitiveness.

Good to Know:

Management standards in Japan are deeply rooted in cultural values like respect for hierarchy and the importance of consensus, which manifest in practices such as nemawashi, ringi-sho, and kaizen. Nemawashi involves informally discussing ideas before formal decision-making, thereby fostering consensus, while ringi-sho is a documented approval process by managers. Kaizen, which advocates continuous improvement, is widely applied as seen at Toyota, where every employee participates in process optimization. Unlike more individualistic Western methods, these practices emphasize the importance of interpersonal relationships and collective harmony. However, globalization and recent reforms, such as strengthening independent governance, are pushing some Japanese companies to adopt Western approaches to enhance their global competitiveness.

Transparency in Japanese Corporate Governance

1) Historical Evolution of Transparency

The improvement of transparency in Japanese companies truly began in the 1990s, following the burst of the economic bubble. During this period, numerous scandals and economic stagnation highlighted the need for corporate governance reform.

Particularly in the 2000s, external and internal control systems were introduced, and in 2015, the establishment of the Corporate Governance Code standardized information disclosure criteria. This code promoted the protection of shareholder rights and strengthened board functions, encouraging transparency improvements across Japanese companies.

2) Current Regulations and Laws

Currently, transparency improvement in Japan is primarily guided by the Corporate Governance Code. Although this guideline is not mandatory, it requires compliance with principles or explanation for non-compliance, following the “comply or explain” principle.

Furthermore, information disclosure requirements in annual reports have expanded to include not only financial information but also ESG (environmental, social, governance) related information. Through this, investor confidence is increasing.

3) Cultural Factors and Transparency

Japan’s unique collectivist culture and lifetime employment system can incline decision-making processes toward non-transparent, consensus-based models. Additionally, the practice of valuing harmony (wa) may discourage questioning problems.

4) Success Examples

For example, Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Limited is recognized for its advanced sustainability-related information disclosures (adopting the TCFD framework) and developing reports that reflect investor needs. Similarly, Asahi Group Holdings, Ltd. receives high evaluations for systematically organizing content through collaboration between key departments.

5) Current Challenges

  • Form vs Substance: Problem of lacking criteria to measure reform effects.
  • SME Support Measures: Absence of measures to alleviate compliance system burden.
  • Global Competitiveness: Insufficient language adaptation, including English publication capabilities.

Good to Know:

Transparency in Japanese corporate governance has evolved significantly since the 1990s, with reforms to the Corporate Code of Conduct following Japan’s economic crisis, which strengthened investor confidence by requiring more financial and informational disclosure. The Financial Regulation Improvement Act and the 2015 Corporate Governance Code now encourage companies to provide clear reporting to protect shareholders. Yet, cultural differences, such as hierarchy and preserving harmony, can hinder optimal transparency implementation. Companies like Toyota and Sony exemplify good practices by proactively publishing detailed sustainability reports, which has boosted investor trust. Despite this, companies must overcome challenges related to transparency, including internal resistance and compliance with international standards, to continue progressing in a competitive globalized economy.

Corporate Social Responsibility in Japan

Importance and Method of CSR Integration

Recently in Japan, CSR has evolved from a simple responsibility to a strategy aimed at increasing corporate value. Companies are increasingly turning to long-term growth by integrating social considerations such as environmental protection and human rights respect, in addition to profit-seeking.

Notable Examples

  • Fujifilm: Use of renewable energy, nature conservation activities, and medical technical support in emerging countries.
  • Bridgestone: Disaster recovery assistance, water quality conservation activities for Lake Biwa, and contribution to safety education programs.
  • Komatsu: Development of construction machinery reducing CO2 emissions and support projects for landmine clearance.

Legal Framework and Influence

As a government-led initiative, the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry established an expert advisory panel in 2004, recommending a private sector-centered approach emphasizing autonomy and diversity.

Alignment Efforts with SDGs

Many Japanese companies commit to promoting the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). For example, Daiwa House Industry implements measures addressing multiple goals, such as providing housing services for the elderly.

Challenges and Opportunities

Main CSR Challenges in Japan
ChallengeImpact
Increased CostsShort-term burden for environmental technologies
Stakeholder CoordinationDifficulty meeting varied needs
Result MeasurementLack of clear evaluation criteria

Good to Know:

CSR holds a growing place in Japan, strategically integrating into corporate governance through increased societal pressure and high expectations for transparency and ethics. Companies like Toyota and Suntory stand out for their commitment to the environment and community, with Toyota implementing energy-efficient production models and Suntory investing in water resource preservation. The legislative framework, strengthened by the Sustainability Law and METI guidelines, amplifies these efforts, requiring compliance and encouraging contribution to the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Despite these advances, Japanese companies face challenges such as CSR innovation and integrating these practices into their traditional business model, but also see opportunities in international collaboration and developing sustainable technological solutions.

Business Ethics in Japanese Culture

Core Values

In Japan, values such as “respect,” “honesty,” and “harmony” are highly valued in business transactions. These values form an ancient cultural foundation, influenced particularly by Confucianism and the spirit of bushido.

Historical Influence

Confucian thought also has significant impact on Japanese business ethics. The emphasis on “altruism” and “human relationships” fosters interpersonal relations and cooperation within groups.

Examples of Ethical Practices

Ethical Practices of Japanese Companies
CompanyInitiative
ToyotaDevelopment of environmental technologies
HitachiSocial innovation projects
UniqloSupply chain transparency

Ethical Issues in Globalization

During global expansion, Japanese companies face new challenges such as intercultural friction, responding to human rights issues, and strengthening fraud prevention measures.

Good to Know:

In Japanese culture, business ethics are deeply rooted in traditional values such as respect, honesty, and harmony, strongly influenced by Confucianism, which advocates morality and collective responsibility. Japanese companies, often perceived as social actors, actively engage in collective well-being, integrating social responsibility into their business model, as illustrated by Toyota with its ecological initiatives. The systematic implementation of these values positively influences their global reputation, but they must also navigate the ethical challenges imposed by a globalized context, where local traditions and international expectations converge.

Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or professional advice. We encourage you to consult qualified experts before making any investment, real estate, or expatriation decisions. Although we strive to maintain up-to-date and accurate information, we do not guarantee the completeness, accuracy, or timeliness of the proposed content. As investment and expatriation involve risks, we disclaim any liability for potential losses or damages arising from the use of this site. Your use of this site confirms your acceptance of these terms and your understanding of the associated risks.

About the author
Cyril Jarnias

Cyril Jarnias is an independent expert in international wealth management with over 20 years of experience. As an expatriate himself, he is dedicated to helping individuals and business leaders build, protect, and pass on their wealth with complete peace of mind.

On his website, cyriljarnias.com, he shares his expertise on international real estate, offshore company formation, and expatriation.

Thanks to his expertise, he offers sound advice to optimize his clients' wealth management. Cyril Jarnias is also recognized for his appearances in many prestigious media outlets such as BFM Business, les Français de l’étranger, Le Figaro, Les Echos, and Mieux vivre votre argent, where he shares his knowledge and know-how in wealth management.

Find me on social media:
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Our guides: