wp:paragraph
Buying, holding, or selling a property in Spain is no trivial matter for a French taxpayer. Between local Spanish taxes, capital gains taxation, wealth tax on both sides of the Pyrenees, and the complex mechanisms of the Franco-Spanish tax treaty, the bill can quickly add up… or, conversely, be significantly optimized if you know the rules.
This article explains in plain language how properties are taxed in Spain, the differences between resident and non‑resident, how IRNR works, the effects of the tax treaty, and the allocation of tax on a real estate capital gain between France and Spain.
Tax residency: the starting point of any analysis
Before talking about local taxes, rents, or capital gains, one key question must be answered: are you a tax resident in Spain or France? The answer conditions almost everything else.
The Spanish definition of tax residency
Spanish domestic law (Article 9 of the IRPF Law) sets out three main criteria:
Spanish tax residency is determined by several conditions: staying at least 183 days in the calendar year, having your main economic interests in Spain, or a presumption based on the residency of your spouse and minor children, unless proven otherwise.
Otherwise, you are considered a non‑resident and then fall under the Non‑Resident Income Tax (IRNR) only on your Spanish-source income.
The French definition and residency conflicts
On the French side (Article 4 B of the CGI), you are a French tax resident if you have:
– your home or main place of stay, or
– your main professional activity, or
– the center of your economic interests.
The Franco-Spanish tax treaty of October 10, 1995, based on the OECD model, determines the country of residence when a person is considered a resident of both states under their domestic laws.
1. State where you have a permanent home available to you. 2. If you have a home in both states: State where your center of vital interests lies (personal and economic ties). 3. Otherwise: State of habitual abode. 4. As a last resort: nationality or mutual agreement between administrations.
This residency status, once determined under the treaty, sets which country has the primary right to tax your worldwide income, and within what limits the other state may also tax certain income (especially real estate).
Local Spanish taxes: IBI, IRNR, and other holding taxes
For a French owner of a property in Spain, there is first the “usage” taxation: what you pay each year simply for holding the property, even without using it.
IBI: the Spanish equivalent of property tax
IBI (Impuesto sobre Bienes Inmuebles) is the Spanish property tax. It is owed by every property owner, resident or not, and is calculated on the cadastral value (valor catastral), an administrative value generally much lower than the market price (often 30% to 60% of the actual price).
Each municipality sets its own rate within a range established by the state. In practice, this gives:
| Element | Indicative Data |
|---|---|
| Tax base | Cadastral value of the property |
| Typical urban rate | About 0.4% to 1.1% |
| Typical rural rate | About 0.3% to 0.9% |
| Frequency | Annual (bill often in the fall) |
| Payment | To the town hall / local treasury (often by direct debit) |
Differences between municipalities are significant: a large seaside resort or a popular coastal city may have a rate close to 1%, while an inland village will have a 0.4% rate.
Taxation of non-residents: IRNR and “deemed” income
If you are tax resident in France and own a property in Spain, you are in principle a non-resident for Spanish tax purposes. You then fall under IRNR (Impuesto sobre la Renta de No Residentes) for all Spanish-source income, including real estate.
In Spain, even if you do not rent out your home, it is considered to provide a benefit equivalent to rent. This generates a theoretical income called imputed income.
The taxable base is a percentage of the cadastral value:
| Cadastral situation of the property | Percentage applied to the cadastral value |
|---|---|
| Cadastral value revised within the last 10 years | 1.1% |
| Cadastral value not revised within the last 10 years | 2% |
On this base, an IRNR rate that depends on your country of residence is applied:
| Owner’s residence | IRNR rate on the imputed base |
|---|---|
| EU/EEA resident (including France) | 19% |
| Non-EU/EEA resident | 24% |
In other words, a French non-resident owner pays each year 19% of 1.1% or 2% of the cadastral value, as a theoretical income, even if the property remains empty. This tax is declared using Form Modelo 210, to be filed no later than December 31 of the year following the tax year.
IRNR on rents: 19% on the net for French residents
When the property is rented, the rents received also fall under IRNR. The treatment again depends on your residence zone.
For a French national resident within the EU or EEA, the applicable tax status is that of a community resident, which may involve specific filing obligations and the application of European tax directives.
– Rate: 19%
– Tax base: net income: rents collected minus deductible expenses (IBI, mortgage interest, community fees, insurance, maintenance work, agency fees, etc.), prorated for the rented periods.
For a non‑resident from outside the EU/EEA:
– Rate: 24%
– Tax base: in principle gross income (without deduction of expenses), even though European and Spanish case law is moving toward aligning the right to deductions to avoid discrimination.
Since the reform applicable to 2024 income, non‑resident landlords declare their rents once a year (still via Modelo 210) between January 1 and 20 of the following year. Before this reform, the declaration was quarterly.
Note: if the property is rented only part of the year, the owner must in principle file two Modelo 210 declarations:
– one for the rented period (actual income),
– one for the non‑rented period (theoretical imputed income for the vacant days).
Taxation of real estate capital gains in Spain
The question that haunts many French property owners in Spain remains: how much will I pay if I sell? And how does this combine with French taxation?
The treaty framework: Article 13 of the tax treaty
The Franco-Spanish tax treaty is very clear on the treatment of real estate capital gains. Article 13 §1 provides that:
> gains from the alienation of immovable property are taxable in the state where that property is situated.
Concretely, a capital gain on property located in Spain is taxable in Spain, whether the seller is a French or Spanish resident. But this does not mean it will never be taken into account in France: the treaty allocates the right to tax, then organizes the elimination of double taxation via a system of tax credits or exemptions.
We will come back to that.
How Spain calculates the real estate capital gain
The basic rules are simple:
> Taxable capital gain = Selling price − (Purchase price + acquisition costs + documented improvement works)
In more detail:
The proceeds from the sale are reduced by selling costs such as agency commission, notary fees, legal fees, and possibly the local municipal capital gains tax borne by the seller.
– 2. Acquisition value This is the purchase price plus initial costs:
– transfer tax (ITP) or VAT and stamp duty if new purchase,
– notary and registration fees,
– legal fees,
– possibly certain duties or taxes paid at the time of purchase.
3. Improvement works You can add expenses for work that increases the value of the property (extensions, major renovation, energy performance), provided you have invoices. Simple repairs or routine maintenance are not deductible for the capital gain.
The result thus obtained is the gross taxable capital gain in Spain.
Capital gains tax rates: residents vs non-residents
Spain distinguishes between tax residents and non-residents.
For non-residents (including French who do not live fiscally in Spain), the rule is simple:
| Non-resident seller situation | IRNR rate on real estate capital gain |
|---|---|
| EU/EEA resident | 19% (single rate) |
| Non-EU/EEA resident | 19% on real estate capital gain (in practice, same rate for real estate sales) |
This 19% rate is collected at source through a special mechanism: at the time of the sale deed, the buyer must withhold 3% of the sale price and pay it to the Spanish Treasury (form Modelo 211). The non-resident seller then has three months (after the month of sale) to file his capital gain declaration (Modelo 210):
When selling a property, if the calculated tax on the gain exceeds 3% of the sale price, the seller must pay the difference. Conversely, if the gain is nil or low, he can request a full or partial refund of the 3% already paid.
For Spanish residents, the real estate capital gain falls into the category of “savings income” (rentas del ahorro), with progressivity:
Recent scales evolve but, to give an order of magnitude, they range from 19% to 30%:
| Capital gain bracket (resident) | Indicative rate (updated scale) |
|---|---|
| Up to €6,000 | 19% |
| €6,001 to €50,000 | 21% |
| €50,001 to €200,000 | 23% |
| €200,001 to €300,000 | 27% |
| Over €300,000 | 30% |
The tax is declared via the annual income tax return (Form 100) between April and June of the year following the sale, with the possibility of spreading payment (e.g., 60% in June, 40% in November).
Capital gain: favorable special cases (Spanish residents)
If you become a Spanish tax resident, certain exemptions may apply:
The sale of the main residence is fully exempt from capital gains tax if the seller is over 65 and has occupied it for at least three years. Reinvesting the sale proceeds in a new main residence within a certain period can also exempt the gain. Finally, investing up to €240,000 of the gain in an annuity contract within six months avoids tax on that portion.
These regimes concern only Spanish tax residents. A French non-resident selling his second home on the Costa Blanca, for example, does not benefit from them.
Municipal capital gains tax (Plusvalía Municipal)
In parallel with the state tax, most Spanish municipalities collect a municipal capital gains tax, a local tax based not on the actual gain on the property, but on the theoretical increase in the value of the land since the purchase.
After a ruling by the Constitutional Court, two calculation methods coexist:
– an “objective” method based on the cadastral value of the land multiplied by an official coefficient and a municipal rate;
– a method based on the actual gain on the land (if the land value has decreased, no tax is due).
The town hall calculates both and retains the most favorable to the taxpayer. This tax is separate from the capital gains tax under IRNR or IRPF.
Franco-Spanish tax treaty: who taxes what, and how to avoid double taxation?
Cross-border real estate taxation rests entirely on the Convention between the Kingdom of Spain and the French Republic for the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of tax evasion and fraud with respect to taxes on income and on capital, signed in 1995.
Taxes covered
For Spain, the treaty covers: the rights of Spanish citizens.
– IRPF (Personal Income Tax),
– IS (Corporate Tax),
– IRNR (Non-Resident Income Tax),
– IP (Wealth Tax, equivalent to the wealth tax),
– and equivalent local taxes on income and wealth.
For France, it covers:
– income tax (IR),
– corporate tax (IS),
– and real estate wealth tax (IFI).
In other words, most real estate taxation (rental income, capital gains, real estate assets) falls within the scope of this treaty.
Rental income: right to tax in the state where the property is located
Article 6 of the treaty provides that income from immovable property is taxable in the state where that property is situated. An apartment in Valencia rented by a French person:
This property is taxable in Spain according to its location. As worldwide income, it must also be declared in France if the owner is a French tax resident.
To avoid double taxation, France applies the tax credit method (Article 24-1-a-ii of the treaty): the French tax calculated on this income is offset by a tax credit equal to the corresponding French tax, but capped at the amount of the theoretical Spanish tax.
In practice, since the effective Spanish rate on rent (19% of the net for a French non-resident) is often lower than the overall French tax burden, the mechanism usually results in an effective exemption in France, but the income must still be declared to determine the effective rate applicable to other income.
Real estate capital gains: taxation in the state where the property is located
Article 13 §1 of the treaty follows the standard OECD rule:
– a gain on property located in Spain is taxable in Spain;
– a gain on property located in France is taxable in France.
But the treaty specifies that this does not always give an exclusive right: the state of residence may also take this gain into account, provided it grants a tax credit.
For a French resident selling a house in Spain:
Tax rules applicable to French residents selling a property in Spain, with a mechanism to avoid double taxation
Spain taxes the gain at 19% for non-residents from outside the EU and withholds 3% of the sale price at source.
France imposes tax on the real estate capital gain: 19% income tax + 17.2% social contributions, with a possible surcharge beyond €50,000 of gain.
To avoid double taxation, Article 24 provides a tax credit creditable against French tax, equal to the tax paid in Spain, but capped at the amount of French tax.
In many situations, the Spanish tax therefore offsets all or part of the income tax component in France. However, the issue of French social contributions (17.2% on real estate capital gains) remains delicate, with the Council of State and the CJEU having already censured some practices and France having reclassified these contributions to maintain them.
Example of eliminated double taxation logic
Imagine a French taxpayer, resident in France, who sells an apartment in Spain with a gain of €100,000.
In Spain (non‑resident EU):
– taxable gain: €100,000,
– IRNR tax = 19% of €100,000 = €19,000,
– withholding of 3% of the price, regularized by a Modelo 210.
In France:
The gain is subject to the French regime (19% income tax + 17.2% social contributions + possible surcharge), but the treaty provides a tax credit on French income tax up to the €19,000 paid in Spain, within the limit of the French income tax due on this gain.
Result: the taxpayer does not pay comparable income tax twice, but remains exposed to French specificities (social contributions, possible surcharge) insofar as the treaty does not always explicitly cover them.
When France exempts and when it credits
The general principle in French treaty law is as follows:
– for certain income, France applies an exemption with progressive rate: the foreign income is not taxed in France, but is taken into account to determine the rate applied to other income;
– for others (including real estate capital gains), it applies the tax credit method: it calculates its own tax, then grants a credit corresponding to the foreign tax, up to the amount of its tax.
In the end, it is rare for a French person to suffer an overall tax burden higher than the heavier of the two systems (French or Spanish) on the “income tax” component. However, one must accept the complexity of dual filings (Form 210 on the Spanish side, Forms 2048‑IMM, 2042, 2047, 2042‑C, or 2074 on the French side).
Wealth tax: real estate assets between French IFI and Spanish IP
Another sensitive topic for French individuals with significant assets: the interplay between the French IFI and the Spanish wealth tax (Impuesto sobre el Patrimonio), supplemented by the solidarity tax on large fortunes.
IFI: the French logic centered on real estate
IFI applies to individuals whose net real estate assets exceed €1.3 million as of January 1. It only covers real estate assets, notably including:
– a 30% discount on the value of the main residence,
– a progressive scale:
| Net real estate asset bracket | IFI rate |
|---|---|
| €0 – €800,000 | 0% |
| €800,000 – €1,300,000 | 0.50% |
| €1,300,000 – €2,570,000 | 0.70% |
| €2,570,000 – €5,000,000 | 1% |
| €5,000,000 – €10,000,000 | 1.25% |
| Over €10,000,000 | 1.50% |
French residents are taxed on their worldwide real estate assets; non-residents only on their assets located in France.
Spanish wealth tax and solidarity tax
Spain stands out by taxing not only real estate but the entire net wealth (accounts, securities, business assets, works of art, vehicles, etc.), via the Impuesto sobre el Patrimonio (IP), to which is added a solidarity tax on large fortunes (ITSGF).
Main features at the state level:
The Spanish wealth tax provides a general allowance of €700,000 per person, plus an additional exemption of €300,000 for the main residence of residents. The taxable base is net wealth as of December 31. The national scale is progressive, from 0.2% to 2.5% depending on the bracket, with a possibility for regional adjustment up to 3.5%.
Autonomous communities may however:
– raise or lower the thresholds,
– modify the scales,
– apply total exemptions (such as Madrid, Andalusia, Murcia) or partial ones.
Added to this is the solidarity tax on large fortunes (ITSGF), applicable to net wealth exceeding €3 million, with a specific scale:
| Net wealth bracket (ITSGF) | Rate |
|---|---|
| €0 – €3,000,000 | 0% |
| €3,000,000 – €5,000,000 | 1.70% |
| €5,000,000 – €10,000,000 | 2.10% |
| Over €10,000,000 | 3.50% |
Amounts paid under the regional IP are deducted from the ITSGF, which acts as a “surcharge” for large fortunes, especially in regions where the IP is reduced (Madrid, Andalusia, Murcia).
Finally, a so-called 60% rule limits the sum of IRPF and IP/ITSGF to 60% of taxable income; beyond that, the wealth tax burden may be reduced (but generally not below 20% of the theoretical amount).
French resident, owner in Spain: who taxes the wealth?
The tax treaty on income and capital also covers wealth taxes (IFI on the French side, IP on the Spanish side). Simplifying:
A French resident owning real estate in Spain may be subject to Spanish wealth tax (if the net value exceeds the applicable thresholds depending on the region) and to French IFI on the same property, since IFI covers worldwide real estate assets.
To avoid double taxation, the treaty provides a tax credit: France includes the Spanish property in the IFI base, then credits against the French IFI due a credit equal to the Spanish tax paid on that same property, up to the portion of IFI corresponding to that asset.
Conversely, a Spanish resident owning real estate in France:
– is subject to IP (and ITSGF if applicable) on his worldwide wealth, including French properties,
– while France may claim IFI on his French properties, with the obligation to grant a Spanish tax credit under the conditions provided.
The concrete result depends greatly on:
– your place of tax residency (France or Spain),
– the structure of your wealth (more or less real estate),
– the Spanish autonomous community of attachment (Madrid vs Catalonia or Valencia, for example),
– and specific exemption rules (main residence, business assets).
Practical impact for a French person: a few typical scenarios
To conclude, it is useful to illustrate how these mechanisms combine in the real life of a French investor or retiree.
Case 1: French resident in France, vacation home in Spain
You live and work in France, but own a second home on the Costa del Sol.
Each year, you are exposed to:
– IBI (local property tax) calculated on the cadastral value;
– IRNR – imputed income: 19% of 1.1% or 2% of the cadastral value (if you do not occupy the property all year);
– possibly IRNR on rents if you occasionally rent it out, at 19% of net income, with deduction of expenses;
– Spanish wealth tax (IP / ITSGF) only if the net value of your Spanish assets exceeds the thresholds (in practice, above €700,000 of net wealth, more or less depending on the region), declared via Modelo 714.
In France:
– you must declare any rents and the value of the property in your IFI assets (above €1.3M of net real estate assets),
– but you benefit from tax credits for the Spanish taxes paid (income and wealth), to avoid excessive double taxation.
When selling:
The Spanish capital gains tax rate for non-residents is set at 19%, while France offsets the tax due with an equivalent tax credit.
Case 2: French person becomes Spanish tax resident with assets in France
You decide to settle permanently in Spain (more than 183 days there, center of your economic interests), while keeping a rental apartment in Lyon.
Consequences:
– you become a Spanish tax resident and fall under IRPF on your worldwide income, as well as IP/ITSGF on your worldwide wealth;
– the rents from Lyon are taxable in France (state where the property is located, Article 6) under French law (micro‑foncier or actual),
– but also taken into account in Spain in your IRPF, with a tax credit for the tax paid in France;
– regarding wealth, the Lyon apartment enters the IP/ITSGF base, while France could still require IFI if you remain considered a French resident (dual residence situation to be resolved under the treaty).
When selling the Lyon apartment:
– France retains the right to tax the capital gain under its own rules,
– Spain must, under the treaty, generally exempt this gain, while possibly taking it into account for the effective rate calculation on your other income.
Case 3: Wealthy French person, tax residency in Spain, large real estate portfolio
If you transfer your tax residency to Spain while retaining a significant real estate portfolio, especially in France, several layers of taxation add up:
– IRPF on worldwide income (including French rents) with credit for tax paid abroad,
– IP and ITSGF on worldwide wealth, including French properties, under the national and regional scales, with allowances of €700,000 and €300,000 for the Spanish main residence,
– more or less favorable coordination with French IFI, depending on whether France still considers you a resident and on the interpretation of the treaty.
In regions like Madrid or Andalusia, where the IP is “neutralized” by a 100% rebate, it is mainly the ITSGF that weighs on assets above €3M, which can remain competitive compared to IFI.
In summary: a heavy but manageable tax burden
Real estate taxation in Spain for French people rests on three pillars:
– Local and national Spanish taxes: IBI, IRNR/IRPF (imputed income, rents, capital gains), IP and ITSGF.
– French taxation: income tax, social contributions, IFI, French capital gains, sometimes with coordination gaps (especially on certain social contributions).
– The Franco-Spanish tax treaty: which allocates taxing rights and organizes the elimination of double taxation through tax credit or exemption.
Properly managed, this structure often allows limiting the overall tax burden to the level of the greedier country, rather than adding up both systems. However, one must:
To optimize your tax situation between France and Spain, you need to clarify your tax residency under the treaty, correctly declare in Spain (Models 210, 211, 714, 100…), coordinate French declarations (2042, 2047, 2048‑IMM, 2042‑IFI, 2074, etc.), and keep up with rapidly evolving regional scales (ITP, IP) as well as case law on deduction rights for non-residents and the status of social contributions.
For a French owner or prospective buyer in Spain, the goal is not so much to avoid paying tax – the treaty does not allow that – but to avoid paying twice for the same thing, and to make the best use of favorable local regimes (main residence, senior exemptions, choice of region, asset structuring) while respecting Franco-Spanish rules.
Have a wealth planning project or a question? Contact us now to speak with a wealth management expert.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or professional advice. We encourage you to consult qualified experts before making any investment, real estate, or expatriation decisions. Although we strive to maintain up-to-date and accurate information, we do not guarantee the completeness, accuracy, or timeliness of the proposed content. As investment and expatriation involve risks, we disclaim any liability for potential losses or damages arising from the use of this site. Your use of this site confirms your acceptance of these terms and your understanding of the associated risks.